Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Russell McOrmond's avatar

You wrote, "It is now up to Alberta and BC to succeed where Quebec has failed"

I read that as "secede where Quebec has failed".

I'm thinking out loud.

Given the much more common origin stories, will there be a restoration of the"United Canadas" claiming the southern parts of what is now called Ontario and Quebec if the Dominion is broken into constituent parts?

Will the governments of the "Canadian" population that represents the 70% that is south of the 49th parallel actually protect the treaties with domestic nationalities for the lands that represent the 80% of Canada's Land Claims that are north of the 49th?

The lack of respect for those treaties with Indigenous nationalities puts the grievances that Canadian settlers have around respect for other treaties (that are to the benefit of the institutions of Canada) into a different context.

A very shortened list I’m thinking about:

* Royal Proclamation (1763)

* Treaty of Niagara (1764)

* Treaty of Paris (1783)

* Haldimand Proclamation (1784)

* Jay Treaty (1794) -- regularly disregarded by Canada when it comes to citizens of domestic nationalities crossing "border". The USA added this treaty to US law, but Canada never did

* War of 1812 – when the British stopped thinking of domestic nationalities as allies, as they stopped pursuing grievances against the USA and instead focused on compromise with the USA and grievances against domestic nationalities.

* Treaty of Ghent (1814)

* Conventions of 1818 and 1825 (The 1825 one will come into play with a changing conceptualization of "Alaska")

* Webster-Ashburton Treaty (1842)

* Oregon Treaty (1846) – critical given there the territory under dispute encompassed the vast region stretching between the southern tip of Russian Alaska (at 54°40' N) and the northern border of Mexican California (at the 42nd parallel, which forms the current southern border of Oregon).

* USA “purchase” of Russian Alaska (1867)

* British North America Act (1867, three months after the “Purchase” of Alaska), bringing together the “United Canadas”, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick into the Dominion of Canada, which was intended to continue to respect pre-existing treaties

* Alaska Boundary Arbitration / Treaty of 1908 & 1925:

With the USA wanting to extend mining/etc within so-called Alaska, I expect the "British Columbia" aspects to be as active in the near decades as grievances with Alberta (1905) and Saskatchewan (1905) have been in recent decades. The grievances that Canada has around the Alaska boundaries seem very hypocritical given the extreme gerrymandering involved in the 1905 imposition by Ottawa of “provinces” into numbered treaty regions within the Northwest Territories.

While the mythology around the Origin Stories of Canada and the USA happened primarily on the east coast, I suspect the next big chapters of those stories will happen within what after the 1870 consolidation became the North West Territories, which was then carved up by the Dominion of Canada institutions in the distant capital of Ottawa.

https://r.flora.ca/p/dangerous-and-divided-world

Ready for more?