The term “Nazi” has devolved into a derogatory catch-all term for anyone that anyone else opposes, losing the powerful meaning it is meant to have through dilution.
The USA and Canada made very different starts to what is now a Federal system of governments.
The US started in the 18th c with powerful State Governments and a new weaker National Government. Canada started in 1867 with a powerfull Federal Government and weaker Provincisal Governments.These two countries travelled in different Government directions.. The US Federal government is trying to hinder State power while Provincial governments have been reducing Federal power.Quebec for example has an expensive Income Tax unit separater from the Federal tax unit and claims a "right " to separate. The US settled that right in the 1860's.Consequently the US Federal Government is claiming too many "rights" while Canadian Provincial Governments such as Quebec and Albertal claim a "right" to separate from Canadsa.In brief, the US Federal Government has too mant"rights" while for example, Quebec has the "right" to ban the English language and refuse many Anglophones from working in Provincial and Municipal jobs.
Curiously, Trump is severely criticized for his"unlawful" actions in Canada while Quebec remains uncriticized for its destruction of English education, place names and signs
I have no time for Trump nor Quebec as regards basic decency to minorities. For Canadians to attack Trump but not Quebec is the pot calling the kettle black.
MAGA (Make Alberta Great Again) and MQGA (Make Quebec Great Again) are political movements. The claim to be able to separate is just that, a claim made for the benefit of political and economic elites in those regions.
The separation of powers between provincial and federal that we see today is pretty much the same. It is a myth that there is a "powerful" federal Canadian government and "weaker" provincial governments. The constitution lays out specific jurisdiction, something that isn't the case in the USA.
All the Federal Dominion government needs to do is rescind Alberta Act 1905 if that government really wants to exit "Canada" as the Government of Alberta doesn't have a land base. The treaties are with the federal Crown, not with provincial Crowns.
The notion that Canadian provinces have some alleged "right" to independence under International, Canadian or Indigenous law was discussed in the book "Sovereign injustice: Forcible inclusion of the James Bay Crees and Cree territory into a sovereign Quebec". While the situation is more complex with Quebec as the treaties are more complex, the ability of the Government of Quebec to separate and retain what the Dominion government granted it jurisdiction over wouldn't happen. If any land would remain at all, it would be a tiny subset of what is claimed as "Quebec" today.
The USA and Canada made very different starts to what is now a Federal system of governments.
The US started in the 18th c with powerful State Governments and a new weaker National Government. Canada started in 1867 with a powerfull Federal Government and weaker Provincisal Governments.These two countries travelled in different Government directions.. The US Federal government is trying to hinder State power while Provincial governments have been reducing Federal power.Quebec for example has an expensive Income Tax unit separater from the Federal tax unit and claims a "right " to separate. The US settled that right in the 1860's.Consequently the US Federal Government is claiming too many "rights" while Canadian Provincial Governments such as Quebec and Albertal claim a "right" to separate from Canadsa.In brief, the US Federal Government has too mant"rights" while for example, Quebec has the "right" to ban the English language and refuse many Anglophones from working in Provincial and Municipal jobs.
Curiously, Trump is severely criticized for his"unlawful" actions in Canada while Quebec remains uncriticized for its destruction of English education, place names and signs
I have no time for Trump nor Quebec as regards basic decency to minorities. For Canadians to attack Trump but not Quebec is the pot calling the kettle black.
MAGA (Make Alberta Great Again) and MQGA (Make Quebec Great Again) are political movements. The claim to be able to separate is just that, a claim made for the benefit of political and economic elites in those regions.
Have you read the British North America Acts?
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/primary+secondary?title=British%20North%20America%20Act
The separation of powers between provincial and federal that we see today is pretty much the same. It is a myth that there is a "powerful" federal Canadian government and "weaker" provincial governments. The constitution lays out specific jurisdiction, something that isn't the case in the USA.
All the Federal Dominion government needs to do is rescind Alberta Act 1905 if that government really wants to exit "Canada" as the Government of Alberta doesn't have a land base. The treaties are with the federal Crown, not with provincial Crowns.
https://r.flora.ca/p/alberta
The notion that Canadian provinces have some alleged "right" to independence under International, Canadian or Indigenous law was discussed in the book "Sovereign injustice: Forcible inclusion of the James Bay Crees and Cree territory into a sovereign Quebec". While the situation is more complex with Quebec as the treaties are more complex, the ability of the Government of Quebec to separate and retain what the Dominion government granted it jurisdiction over wouldn't happen. If any land would remain at all, it would be a tiny subset of what is claimed as "Quebec" today.
https://r.flora.ca/p/why-not-immediately-formally-denounce